A U.S. Marine Tried To Warn A Comrade, Now He Faces A Discharge

Sep 6, 2016
Originally published on September 6, 2016 10:03 am

Four years ago, Jason Brezler sent an urgent message to a fellow Marine in Afghanistan, warning him about a threat. The warning wasn't heeded, and two weeks later, three U.S. troops were dead.

Now the Marine Corps is trying to kick out Maj. Brezler because the warning used classified information.

Solving a problem

Jason Brezler never thought he'd make a career out of the Marine Corps — his family history was FDNY.

"My grandfather was a firefighter, my father was a firefighter and fire chief," he says.

Brezler graduated from the Naval Academy just before Sept. 11, 2001, and deployed twice as a Marine officer. Then he went into the reserves in 2005, and took a job as a rookie firefighter in the Bronx. The Iraq war was burning too, though, and the Marines kept calling for volunteers.

"I had an opportunity to go to Fallujah at the height of the insurgency, came home and said, what the heck, decided to go to Afghanistan," he says.

In 2010 he was at a remote base in Helmand. The mission was to support the local Afghan population against the Taliban. To do that, Brezler found, he also had to help them against corrupt officials of their own government.

"The police in many cases was a destabilizing force — and driving more folks into the arms of the Taliban," Brezler says.

In particular, the local police chief, Sarwar Jan, turned into a problem.

"Sarwar Jan, he was a threat to not only the Afghans but our own Marines," Brezler says.

The chief was maybe linked to the Taliban. He was also alleged to be a pedophile who preyed on local boys — something alarmingly common among Afghan warlords.

Recently there's been a debate about whether U.S. forces should tolerate Afghan allies who keep kids at their barracks. Back in 2010, there was no policy. Brezler couldn't fire Sarwar Jan, but he could kick him off the base.

"We put Sarwar Jan on the next helicopter. And, once he left, we could have probably had a parade the next day through the bazaar. The Afghans were absolutely elated," he says.

Minor spillage

Brezler went home. In the summer of 2012 he was still in the Marine Reserves, and working as a Brooklyn firefighter. On the side he was getting a master's degree.

"I'm sitting at a conference table in Oklahoma, taking I believe a public budgeting class, and I received an email, and the title was 'SARWAR JAN IS BACK,' all caps, exclamation point, exclamation point," he says.

It was a forwarded request for information from a Marine in Helmand. Sarwar Jan was living on a U.S. base again. He'd brought a small group of underage Afghan boys to serve him there.

"My reaction was largely a visceral one. I was like, 'Are you freaking kidding me?' " he says.

Brezler searched his laptop — it was the same one he'd had with him in Helmand — and found the dossier on Sarwar Jan. He attached it, hitting "reply all" and then "send." That set off a chain of consequences, including one Brezler never intended, according to his lawyer, Mike Bowe.

"As soon as he sends it, the Marine on the other side says, 'This is marked classified,' " Bowe says. "So, at the first break during class, [Brezler] calls on his cellphone to his [commanding officer] and he says, 'Look, this is what just happened,' " says Bowe, "so he self-reports right away like he's supposed to do."

Brezler told his commander he had emailed a classified document from a non-secure Yahoo account. His commander, who had served with Brezler in Fallujah, told him to notify their intelligence officer but not worry too much about it.

"He said all right, it sounds like minor spillage," Brezler recalls.

Over the next several months, NCIS (Naval Criminal Investigative Service — because the Marine Corps is technically part of the Navy) would investigate the "spillage" and find that Brezler had classified materiel still on his laptop from his deployment. That would result in a bad fitness report on Brezler's otherwise excellent record of awards and citations.

More immediately, though, the urgent warning he had sent got lost in the concern over spillage.

"What we didn't want to happen"

On Aug. 10, 2012, just 17 days after Brezler's warning, one of Sarwar Jan's underage servants grabbed an assault rifle and killed three unarmed Marines at the base gymnasium in Helmand.

"I don't know if I've ever been so angry and so sad at the same moment in my life. This is precisely what we didn't want to happen," Brezler says.

Brezler felt worse a few months later when he heard that the parents of one of the murdered Marines had no details about their son's death. They were asking for help from their congressman, New York Republican Pete King.

"It was at that point that I said to myself, 'This isn't OK.' That family, they probably don't really know this attack was in the preventable range," he says.

Brezler met with Rep. King, and the congressman started pushing the issue in the media.

And that's when the U.S. Marine Corps got serious — about investigating Jason Brezler.

"Almost a year had gone by from the time, he had moved on, the Marine Corps had moved on," says lawyer Mike Bowe. "A news story comes out that reveals that he's talking to Congressman King about these murders, and three days later he is sent to a Board of Inquiry to be kicked out of the Marine Corps."

The inquiry was retaliation, Bowe says, for embarrassing the Marine Corps brass. He says there were hundreds of similar cases of "spillage" the same year, and only two were punished. A Pentagon inspector general's report concluded it was not retaliation.

After three days of testimony, the board decided Brezler should be put out of the Marine Corps, with an honorable discharge. He wouldn't lose any benefits or rank; Jason Brezler just wouldn't be a Marine anymore.

"In light of my very strong desire to continue to serve and lead Marines, it didn't feel honorable," he says.

Brezler is suing in federal court to stay in the Marines.

A spokeswoman said the Marine Corps has confidence in the legal and administrative processes against Brezler, but declined to comment further because the case is ongoing.

A federal judge put a stay on his dismissal from the Marines until a hearing, and possibly a trial, this fall.

Brezler's case has become celebrated among some troops and veterans. Internet memes compare his treatment to that of Hillary Clinton, who sent some 110 classified emails from her personal server; or to that of Gen. David Petraeus, who lied to the FBI about giving classified material to his mistress. A prominent retired Marine general even invited Brezler to a Marine Corps parade this summer in a gesture of support.

"There's a lot of really great Marines that, throughout this ordeal, have continued to stand to my left and to my right," Brezler says.

Copyright 2017 NPR. To see more, visit http://www.npr.org/.

RENEE MONTAGNE, HOST:

Now to a story that hinges on classified information sent by email. Not another story about Hillary Clinton - this is about a U.S. Marine named Jason Brezler. Four years ago, Brezler sent an urgent message to a fellow Marine in Afghanistan warning him about a threat. The warning was not heeded. And two weeks later, three U.S. troops were dead. Now, the Marine Corps is trying to kick Brezler out because the warning used classified information. NPR veterans correspondent Quil Lawrence has the story.

QUIL LAWRENCE, BYLINE: Jason Brezler deployed four times, including a tour of urban combat in Fallujah. In 2010, he was at a remote base in Helmand, Afghanistan. The mission was to support Afghan forces against the Taliban. Brezler says his biggest problem was a corrupt local police chief.

JASON BREZLER: Sarwar Jan - he was a threat to not only the Afghans but our own Marines.

LAWRENCE: Sarwar Jan was maybe linked to the Taliban. He was also a pedophile who preyed on local boys, something alarmingly common among Afghan warlords. Recently, there's been a debate about whether U.S. forces should tolerate Afghan allies who keep kids at their barracks. Back in 2010, there was no policy. Brezler couldn't fire Sarwar Jan, but he could kick him off the base.

BREZLER: We put Sarwar Jan on the next helicopter, and once he left, we could've probably had a parade the next day through the bazaar. The Afghans were absolutely elated.

LAWRENCE: Brezler went home. In the summer of 2012, he was in the Marine Reserves and working as a Brooklyn firefighter. On the side, he was getting a master's degree.

BREZLER: So I'm sitting at a conference table in Oklahoma taking, I believe, a public budgeting class, and I received an email, and the title was "Sarwar Jan Is Back" - all caps, exclamation point, exclamation point.

LAWRENCE: It was a forwarded request for information from a Marine in Helmand. Sarwar Jan was living on a U.S. base again. He'd brought a small group of underage Afghan boys to serve him there.

BREZLER: And my reaction, it was largely a visceral one. I was like, are you freaking kidding me?

LAWRENCE: Brezler searched his laptop - it was the same one he'd had with him in Helmand - and he found the dossier on Sarwar Jan. He hit reply all and send. That set off a chain of consequences but not the one Brezler intended.

MIKE BOWE: As soon as he sends it, and then the Marine on the other side in Afghanistan says, this is marked classified.

LAWRENCE: That's Jason Brezler's lawyer, Mike Bowe. He sat in on our interview.

BOWE: And so at the first break during class, he calls on his cellphone to his CO and he says, look, this is what just happened. So he self-reports right away like he's supposed to do.

BREZLER: My boss, my battalion commander, who at that point professionally I had known for several years - we had served in Fallujah together at the height of the insurgency - and he said, all right, it sounds like minor spillage.

BOWE: He explained it all to his CO. His CO told him to report it to the intelligence officer. They counseled him, said, OK, well, you know, you shouldn't have done that. The NCIS concluded within a few months that, yes, technically there was a violation of the rules, but no action needed to be taken.

LAWRENCE: Amid all the investigations into Brezler's handling of classified material, the warning he sent got lost. Seventeen days later in Helmand, one of Sarwar Jan's underaged servants grabbed an assault rifle and shot dead three unarmed Marines at the base gymnasium.

BREZLER: I don't know if I've ever been so angry and so sad at the same moment in my life. I mean, this is precisely what we didn't want to happen.

LAWRENCE: Brezler felt worse a few months later when he heard that the parents of one of the murdered Marines had no details about their son's death. They were asking help from their congressman, New York Republican Pete King.

BREZLER: And it was at that point that I said to myself this isn't OK. And that family probably don't even really know this attack was in the preventible range.

LAWRENCE: Brezler met with Congressman King, and King started pushing the issue, and that got some press. And that's when the U.S. Marine Corps got serious about investigating Jason Brezler. Here's Brezler's lawyer again.

BOWE: Almost a year had gone by, and he had moved on, the Marine Corps had moved on. And then a new story comes out that reveals that he's talking to Congressman King about these murders. And three days later, he is sent to a board of inquiry to be kicked out of the Marine Corps.

LAWRENCE: Bowe says there were hundreds of similar cases of spillage in the same year, and only two were punished. The inquiry was retaliation, he says, for embarrassing the Marine brass. A Pentagon inspector general report concluded it was not retaliation.

BREZLER: On day three of the hearing, the BOI, the board recommended that I be separated with an honorable discharge.

LAWRENCE: That's an honorable discharge - no real loss of benefits. Jason Brezler just wouldn't be a Marine anymore.

BREZLER: A huge punch in the gut. In light of my very strong desire to continue to serve and lead Marines, it didn't feel honorable.

LAWRENCE: A spokesman said the Marine Corps has confidence in legal and administrative processes against Jason Brezler but declined to comment further because the case is ongoing. Brezler sued in federal court to stay in the Marines. The case could go to trial this fall. Quil Lawrence, NPR News. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.